Oct 23, 2019 14:42
4 yrs ago
14 viewers *
English term

Indian Act Bands

English to Spanish Law/Patents Law (general) Human Rights
This is referred to new laws created to protect indigenous communities in Canada.

The legislation is expected to allow the Province to enter into agreements with Indigenous governments besides Indian Act Bands and incorporated organizations (such as societies).

From Wikipedia, Indian Act:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Act#"Band"

Indian Act
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
Indigenous peoples
in Canada
A life-sized bronze statue of an Aboriginal and eagle above him; there is a bear to his right and a wolf to his left, they are all looking upwards towards a blue and white sky
First NationsInuitMétis
History[show]
Politics[show]
Culture[show]
Demographics[show]
Linguistics[show]
Religions[show]
Index[show]
Wikiprojects[show]
vte
The Indian Act (An Act respecting Indians, French: Loi sur les Indiens) is a Canadian act of Parliament that concerns registered Indians, their bands, and the system of Indian reserves.[1][2] First passed in 1876 and still in force with amendments, it is the primary document which defines how the Government of Canada interacts with the 614 First Nation bands in Canada and their members. Throughout its long history the Act has been an ongoing subject of controversy and has been interpreted in different ways by both Aboriginal Canadians and non-Aboriginal Canadians. The legislation has been amended many times, including "over twenty major changes" made by 2002.[3]

The Act is very wide-ranging in scope, covering governance, land use, healthcare, education, and more on Indian reserves. Notably, the original Indian Act does two things affecting all indigenous peoples in Canada:

It says how reserves and bands can operate. The Act sets out rules for governing Indian reserves, defines how bands can be created and spells out the powers of "band councils". Bands do not have to have reserve lands to operate under the act.[4]
It defines who is, and who is not recognized as an "Indian". The Act defines a number of types of Indian people who are not recognized as "registered" or "status" Indians and who are therefore denied membership in bands.[4]
The Act's existence is necessitated by the fact that First Nations (historically called "Indians") relate differently to the state because of inherited legal arrangements such as the Royal Proclamation of 1763 and various treaties, and because Canada's constitution specifically assigns indigenous issues to the federal, rather than provincial, governments, by the terms of Section 91(24) of the Constitution Act, 1867. The Act replaced any laws on the topic passed by a local legislature before a province joined Canadian Confederation, creating a definitive national policy on the subject. The Act is not a treaty; it is Canada's legal response to the treaties. Nevertheless, its unilateral nature, imposed on indigenous peoples by the Canadian government in contrast to the treaties, is itself a source of discontent among indigenous peoples in Canada.

------------

And "Band":

"Band"
Main article: Band government
In the Indian Act, updated to April 2013, the term "band",[4]

means a body of Indians (a) for whose use and benefit in common, lands, the legal title to which is vested in Her Majesty, have been set apart before, on or after September 4, 1951, (b) for whose use and benefit in common, moneys are held by Her Majesty, or (c) declared by the Governor in Council to be a band for the purposes of this Act.

— Indian Act[7]

Discussion

Robert Carter Oct 23, 2019:
I agree with Sara [and by extension John Rhynne] Sociopolitical typology refers to four types, or levels, of a political organization: "band", "tribe", "chiefdom", and "state", created by the anthropologist Elman Service.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociopolitical_typology

Here's a University of Zaragoza professor on these classifications:

"1. BANDA. Nivel de integración sociocultural de cazadores y recolectores. Todas las funciones son ejercidas por un breve número de bandas asociadas compuestas por familias nucleares relacionadas entre sí. No hay unidades de producción o consumo específicas ni órganos especializados en lo político, religioso, etc. Las bandas tienden a ser patrilocales, virilocales y exógamas."
https://www.unizar.es/hant/POA/tribus.html
Sara Fairen Oct 23, 2019:
Sí, es correcto usar "banda" si se está hablando de sociedades de cazadores-recolectores, y en ese caso debo corregir mi sugerencia. "Sociedad de bandas" es una categoría sociopolítica distinta de las tribus.

https://ocw.unican.es/pluginfile.php/2209/mod_resource/conte...



El 
grupo 
sociopolítico 
más 
elemental 
que
 se 
conoce 
es 
la 
banda,
 que 
constituye 
el 
agregado 
propio 
de
 las 
sociedades 
más 
simples 
de 
las 
que 
se 
tiene 
constancia, 
que 
son 
las 
de 
cazadores‐recolectores,
 las
 cuales
 han
 llegado
 a
 nuestro
 tiempo
 formando
 islas,
 cada
 vez
 más
 escasas,
 en
 el
 seno
 de
 algunos
 Estados
 actuales,
 abocadas
 a
 una
 desaparición
 inminente,
 por
 el
 simple
 contacto
 con
 otros
 grupos
 completamente
 organizados.
 La
 banda,
 como
 agregado
 rudimentario,
 se
 encuentra,
 entonces,
 en
 aquellas
 sociedades 
que 
aún 
no
 han 
alcanzado 
el 
umbral
 de 
la domesticación 
de 
las
plantas 
y
 de 
los
 animales,
 de
 manera
 que
 corresponde
 con
 el
 grupo
 económico
 y
 político
 por
 excelencia
 de
 las
 sociedades
 paleolíticas 
europeas (...).

Proposed translations

50 mins
Selected

bandas según la definición de la Ley sobre Indios

A suggestion
Note from asker:
Hi John, thanks for your answer. Thing is that "bandas" really doesn't sound too appropriate to me in Spanish. It doesn't make sense, unless it is a specific legal term that I am not familiar with.
Peer comment(s):

neutral Robert Carter : I think you're right about "bandas", the problem I have is with "indios", which is used pejoratively in Mexico. "Indígenas" would be more appropriate IMO. Saludos!//My point is that it sounds much worse in Spanish, at least in Mexico, if not in Spain.
4 hrs
"Indian" sounds wrong in English too, but the law is still called that, and they haven't renamed it in all this time. Let's not try to be more politically correct than the reference text.
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks! I like this idea, but I'd use Asuntos Indígenas instead of "Indios""
+1
1 hr

tribus según la Ley de Asuntos Indígenas

Hay dos elementos a traducir aquí. El primero, bands, en este contexto sería posiblemente grupo o tribu. Indian Act sería, según quién lo traduzca, la Ley de Asuntos Indios o incluso la Ley de Asuntos Indígenas.
https://moose.cec.org/moose/lawdatabase/ca20.cfm?varlan=espa...
Algunos reglamentos federales en la materia incluyen el Reglamento sobre Madera de los Indígenas (Indian Timber Regulations o Règlement sur le bois de construction des indiens) adoptado en virtud de la Ley de Asuntos Indígenas (Indian Act o Loi sur les indiens) ...


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hora (2019-10-23 16:01:26 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

O la Ley sobre las Primeras Naciones

https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=1yCQGFdeoMIC&pg=PT35&lpg...

La Ley de Creación del Tribunal Especifico de Reclamos (Specific Claims ... 2 La Ley sobre las Primeras Naciones (Indian Act) sigue siendo el principal vehículo para el ejercicio de jurisdicción federal...
Peer comment(s):

agree Manuel Aburto
4 hrs
Muchas gracias, Manuel :-)
Something went wrong...
2 hrs

Consejos comunitarios según la Ley de asuntos indios

The key fact that the term “Bands” appears in your text capitalized made me think, with a middle confidence level though, that its meaning might be other than “tribe” or “group” in this particular case. I then looked into the meaning and found a distinctive definition of Band (in uppercase!), which reads as follows:

Definition of Band (capitalized!). Then, later, “band” (lowercase!) is also defined:
http://indigenousfoundations.arts.ubc.ca/bands/
Bands
What is a band?
A “Band”, or “Indian Band,” is a governing unit of Indians in Canada instituted by the Indian Act, 1876. The Indian Act defines a “band” as a “body of Indians,”
a) “for whose use and benefit in common, lands, the legal title to which is vested in Her Majesty, have been set apart”
b) has funds held for it by the federal government, and
c) is declared a band by the Governor-in-Council.1


A Band is, as per the definition above, a “governing unit of Indians in Canada”. So, right, since the authors of your text have written “Bands”, not “bands”, they might well not be referring to the peoples themselves, i.e. groups or tribes as such, but perhaps to one of the specific governing bodies of those groups. This possibility seems quite logical to me since Canadian Provinces need to talk to representatives of groups of Indian people (to enter into agreements in this case), they do not speak with the people directly, I understand. Hence my translation suggestion here.

As for the translation of “Bands” (capitalized) I suggest “consejos comunitarios”, as it appears in the following reference directly related to the situation of indigenous peoples in Canada.

https://www.aacademica.org/iii.congreso.chileno.de.antropolo...
Autogobierno Indígena: El Caso de Canadá.
(…)
De la Hermandad India se pasó, en la década siguiente, a constituirse la Asamblea de las Primeras Naciones (First Nations Assembly), la que representaba oficialmente a los Indios que vivían en Reservas o Reducciones Indígenas o estaban todavía asociados a ellas. Estos sumaban más de 600 mil almas y eran reconocidos en la Ley Indígena como Status Indians y su Asamblea Nacional los representaba ante el Gobierno Federal y los gobiernos provinciales. Fuera de defender a las Reservas Indígenas y apoyar a sus consejos comunitarios (llamados Indian Bands) y fomentar la cultura y la educación indígena, su lucha política principal era por los derechos a sus tierras. También insistían en lo que llamaban sus Derechos Inherentes, heredados de su prolongado pasado histórico cultural.


And finally with regard to “Indian Act”, I suggest to use “Ley de Asuntos Indios”, which is the rendering used by Amnesty International. Other possible alternatives are “Ley sobre comunidades aborígenes” or “Ley indígena”. There are probably other options.

https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/92000/amr20001200...
Canadá
“HERMANAS ROBADAS”
Discriminación y violencia contra las mujeres indígenas en Canadá
Resumen de las preocupaciones de Amnistía Internacional
El alcance de la violencia
Un impactante documento estadístico del gobierno canadiense, elaborado en 1996, revela que las mujeres indígenas de entre 25 y 44 años, cuya condición se define en la Ley de Asuntos Indios (Indian Act), tenían cinco veces más posibilidades que otras mujeres de la misma edad de morir a causa de la violencia.
Something went wrong...
3 hrs

grupos/bandos/pueblos bajo la ley india/indígena

Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search